|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 6-10
Pattern of unnatural death among females in niger delta: A retrospective medicolegal study
Eseroghene Arthur Ijomone1, Obiora Jude Uchendu2, Nkadi Francis Nwachokor3
1 Department of Pathology, Central Hospital, Sapele, Nigeria
2 Department of Histopathology, Delta State University, Delta State, Abraka, Nigeria
3 Department of Pathology, Igbinedion University, Okada, Edo State, Nigeria
|Date of Web Publication||14-May-2019|
Dr. Obiora Jude Uchendu
Department of Histopathology, Delta State University, Abraka, Delta State
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: Unnatural death among women is rarely emphasized but an important public health index of the community and society. Objective: The objective is to study the epidemiologic profile of unnatural death among females using autopsy data. Design: This is a 14-year descriptive retrospective study of all female unnatural death victims within Warri and its neighboring communities subjected to medicolegal autopsy. Materials and Methods: Information on age as well as manner and method of death were extracted from the autopsy report of the cases and subsequently analyzed using Microsoft Office Excel 2007. Results: Ninety-six females were examined in this study, representing 9.9% of the 975 medicolegal performed and 11.4% of the 805 unnatural deaths encountered during the study period. The age range is 1–70 years and the mean age is 29.82 years. These cases represent a mean annual incidence of about seven cases. The peak incidence of unnatural death occurred in the third decade (27.1%), followed by the fourth (19.8%) and fifth (15.6%) decades, respectively. The peak incidence for homicide and accidental deaths is in the third and fourth decades, respectively. Firearm-related death is the leading method of homicide accounting for 24 (53.3%) of the 45 homicide deaths. The use of blunt and sharp weapons each accounts for 10 (22.2%) of the cases. Road traffic accident (RTA) accounts for 28 cases, representing 59.6% of accidental deaths and 29.1% of unnatural deaths. Burns and drowning are the second and third leading causes of accidental death accounting for 11 (23.4%) and 3 (6.4%) of the accidental deaths. Four cases of suicide were encountered with three deaths as a result of ingestion of chemical poisons, while the fourth case was by hanging using rope. Conclusion: The study showed that unnatural deaths in women are mainly accidental, homicidal, and suicidal representing 49.0%, 46.0%, and 4.2% of the cases respectively. RTA, burns, drowning, and poisoning (in descending order) are the major causes of accidental deaths. Firearm, sharp, and blunt injuries (in descending order) are the major methods of executing homicides. The peak age for unnatural death is in the third decade with 75% of the death clustering within the 2nd–4th decade. Education, accident consciousness, parental supervision, and implementation of appropriate policy measures are paramount to reducing such death.
Keywords: Accident, firearm, homicide, injuries, suicide, unnatural death
|How to cite this article:|
Ijomone EA, Uchendu OJ, Nwachokor NF. Pattern of unnatural death among females in niger delta: A retrospective medicolegal study. Ann Trop Pathol 2019;10:6-10
|How to cite this URL:|
Ijomone EA, Uchendu OJ, Nwachokor NF. Pattern of unnatural death among females in niger delta: A retrospective medicolegal study. Ann Trop Pathol [serial online] 2019 [cited 2019 Nov 22];10:6-10. Available from: http://www.atpjournal.org/text.asp?2019/10/1/6/258167
| Introduction|| |
Unnatural death refers to category of death considered by coroner or medical examiner as not arising from diseases or normal aging process. Such deaths occur prematurely against the course of nature and result from the triad of homicide, accident, and suicide.
Unnatural deaths tend to reflect the law and order situation in a particular jurisdiction. Where such indices are low, it implies that the environment is peaceful and harmonious and is an indication of security of life and property. It is also one of the indicators of social and mental health and overall a public health indicators of the society.
While global trend shows that it is generally more prevalent among the males, death of females, especially mothers, has serious social, economic, mental, and psychological consequences on the family members and community., Besides, gender inequality, domestic violence and burns related deaths appear to be more common among females.,
In developing countries like ours where vital registrations are poor and death occurs commonly outside the health-care facility, medicolegal autopsy remains an important vital tool for studying unnatural death. The present work is aimed at studying unnatural death among females in Warri, Delta state, Nigeria, using autopsy database. We hope that findings from this study will improve the understanding of the risk factors and guide government in policy prevention strategies.
| Materials and Methods|| |
The city of Warri doubles as an oil exploration town and the commercial capital of Delta state and therefore a preferred residency to many.
The study is a 14-year descriptive retrospective study of all cases of female unnatural death brought in for postmortem examination in Warri and it surrounding communities from January 1, 2003, to December 31, 2016.
The age, method, and manner of death were extracted from their autopsy reports and further analyzed with Microsoft Office Excel 2013. The results are further summarized in tables.
Patients with incomplete records or inconclusive cause of death were excluded from the study.
The ethical approval for this study was granted by the Research and Ethical Committee of Central Hospital, Warri (reference CHW/ECC VOL1/124).
| Results|| |
Ninety-six females were examined in this study, representing 9.9% of the 975 medicolegal autopsies performed and 11.4% of the 805 of the unnatural deaths encountered during the study period. The age range is 1–70 years and the mean age is 29.82 years.
The yearly distribution of the unnatural deaths is shown in [Table 1] with a range of 3–11 cases per annum and a mean annual incidence of about 7 cases.
The age distribution of cases is shown in [Table 2]. The peak incidence of unnatural death occurred in the third decade (27.1%), followed by the fourth (19.8%) and fifth (15.6%) decades, respectively. The peak incidence for homicide and accidental deaths is in the third and fourth decades, respectively.
The pattern of homicides is shown in [Table 3]. The age range of the homicide victims is 12–68 years and the mean age is 32.89 years. Firearms is the most common method of homicide accounting for 24 (53.3%) of the 45 homicide deaths. The use of blunt and sharp weapons each accounts for 10 (22.2%) of the cases.
The pattern of accidental death in this study is shown in [Table 4]. Their mean age and the age range(in years) are 29.34 years and 1-70 years respectively. Road traffic accident (RTA) accounts for 28 cases, representing 59.6% of accidental deaths and 29.1% of unnatural deaths. Burns and drowning are the second and third leading causes of accidental deaths representing 11(23.4%) and 3(6.4%) of such cases respectively.
Four of the deaths were suicide cases. In three cases, it was committed by using fast-acting poisons. The forth case involved applying a ligature round the neck. The detail is shown in [Figure 1].
| Discussion|| |
In this scientific investigation, 96 female autopsy cases were examined, accounting for 9.9% of medicolegal deaths in this series. This relatively gender discrepancy in unintentional and violent injury-related mortality may be attributed to the difference in risk exposure and risk-taking behavior across both genders. Interestingly, it speaks volume of the overall poor involvement of women in the economic landscape of sub-Saharan Africa. Relatively less number of accidental cases are reported to the coroner  resulting in overall low-rate medicolegal autopsy rate among females. We are of the opinion that since it is a patriarchal society, there is a sociocultural tendency to overprotect the female gender, leading to an inherent tendency to report more male death cases to the coroner for investigation than female cases. The incidence in this region is, however, lower than those reported in Port Harcourt, Benin city, and Ibadan  (all in Nigeria) where female deaths constituted 24.2%, 34.6%, and 37.0% of medicolegal autopsies, respectively.
The peak age for female unnatural deaths was at the third decade, representing 27.1% of the cases, with 75% of the cases clustered within the second and fourth decades. This parallels the peak age of physical and entrepreneurial activity in males. This age also spans through the reproductive age and therefore may be partly related to exposure to intimate partner and domestic violence. Boy/girl or marital relationship is usually such that the women are usually much younger than their male partners, accounting for power inequality and consequent female gender vulnerability subSahara Africa.
One of the features of this research is the paucity of cases of unnatural death in the first decade.
We think that such cases are unlikely to be reported to the corner for medical examination since such decisions are to be taken by an adult who perceives such death as a taboo. However, despite the masking effect provided by the attitude of adults, we are of the opinion that infanticide, child kidnapping, abduction, abuse, ritual killing are not uncommon occurrence in this environment. It is also reasonable to believe that with the inherent vulnerability of children to accidental injuries, and the present state of our health-care response to injured victims, that accidental death in children has potentially high fatality. This opinion is supported by a study by Viner et al. which rated sub-Sahara Africa as having the one of the highest rates of child homicide globally. Similarly, Akhiwu et al., in Benin, reported that death among females under the age of 10 years accounted for 4.2% of the medicolegal deaths in Benin city. These deaths result from complex interplay of factors including genetic predisposition, environmental factors, parental factors, poor risk assessment, and curiosity. Earlier studies in this region has seriously blamed lapses in parental supervision. Punishment of such parents should be passed into law as a deterrent for others.
The report showed that accidental death represents the most common, whereas suicide death is least common manner of death. The major burden of accidental deaths is as a result of RTA which represents the single overall most common cause of death in this study. These victims are mostly pedestrians and passengers as the use of women as commercial motorcycle or vehicle drivers, conductors, or road haulage workers is still unpopular in West Africa. The high rate of RTA in West Africa is attributed to deteriorating road network, unworthy cars driven by miscreants, the use of motorbikes as major means of transport, disobedience to safety rules, and lax safety regulating officials. Banning of the use of motorbikes will not only reduce RTA rate but also will reduce rate of homicide-related deaths in major cities of the country since it has also provided an efficient and flexible transportation means for hoodlums.
Another observation in this study is that unnatural death among females was caused mostly by firearms, accounting for 53% of homicide deaths and 25% of female unnatural deaths. This is in contrast with earlier reports that showed that females are more often killed with blunt and sharp weapons. We also observed a peak age of firearm homicide in the third decade which parallel peak age for youthful life. The relatively high firearm-related mortality is in line with the inherent high morbidity associated with firearm injuries, aggravated by the deplorable state of the health sector. This is also a reflection of gun availability which is silently gaining an epidemic magnitude. Illicit arm deals, porous borders, inadequate border protection, arms distribution to thugs by politicians, security sector black marketeering and rentals, local manufacturing, local arm production, rising trend of armed robbery and kidnapping, Niger Delta militancy, cult and gang membership, and herder terrorism are major underlying factors. Firearm and knife legislation must be enforced to check this ugly trend. There is, however, research gap in identifying the perpetrators which call for further study.
Burn death is mainly accidental and homicidal in this study. Accidental death cases include seven kerosene stoves and two gas cooker-related accidents, whereas homicidal deaths resulted from two fatal acid baths. The peak age was in the fourth decade. The use of adulterated cooking fuel is a common observation in this region and may be responsible for such cases. The traditional role of woman as family cook specifically predisposes them to such hazards. There is a need to have a preventive program through a more in-depth research on the underlying risk factors. The lack of burn intensive care unit as well as lack of well-trained staff to manage difficult cases in this region is an important factor to the fatality of burn injury. Better architectural design of the kitchen will reduce risk of kitchen fire accidents.
Drowning has been observed as uncommon causes of death, a reminder that it is still a public health issue in developing country, with all cases involving children. Such drowning arises from poor parental supervision of children and from the use of water as major means of transport in this region. There is a need to focus prevention strategy on parents, caretakers, and the home environment and the need for bystander resuscitation.
Carbon monoxide poisoning death was observed in two cases. We also think that this is a tip of the iceberg because people often die in droves in the country as a result of this poisonous colorless, odorless, and tasteless gas. Major sources at home include use of charcoal to generate heat and generators as source of electricity., With increasing urbanization and the use of generators as source of electricity in the backdrop of epileptic power supply, such cases will continue to abound. Public education, improving design of home, and the use of carbon monoxide detectors are the key to preventing further recurrence.
Two cases of accidental chemical poisoning were reported in this scientific data. Accidental poisoning has been known as a common cause of morbidity and mortality in children, usually attributed to their inherent impulsive and curious nature. As a rule, all drugs, chemicals, and poisons should be kept out of the reach of children to prevent such occurrence.
The rarity of suicide among females in this study is in line with the general incidence in the country. This is probably because of the patriarchal nature of the society that tends to place the burden of running home on the males. However, the few cases may not be unrelated to mental illness. We also observed that most cases are due to ingestion of drugs. This is because women are generally less impulsive in their actions and are more likely to use methods that are neither immediately lethal nor disfiguring.
| Conclusion|| |
The study showed that unnatural deaths in women consists of accidental, homicidal, and suicidal representing 49.0%, 46.0%, and 4.2% of the cases respectively. RTA, burns, drowning, and poisoning (in descending order) are the major causes of accidental deaths. Firearm, sharp, and blunt injuries (in descending order) are the major methods of executing homicides. The peak age for unnatural death is in the third decade with 75% of the death clustering within the 2nd–4th decade. Education, accident consciousness, parental supervision, and implementation of appropriate policy measures are paramount to reducing such death.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Barak A, Haque SM. Investigation of unnatural death. AKMMC J 2014:5;34-8.
Sharma DK, Meena SP, Punia RK, Pathak D. Comparative trends of accidental to intentional mortalities over one-year period at a tertiary care centre. Int J Res Med Sci 2018:6;1574-78.
Rahim M, Das TC. Mortuary profile for unnatural deaths at Forensic medicine department of Dhaka medical college. Bangladesh Med J 2009;38:44-7.
Kumar A. Epidemiological study of unnatural death pattern in Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh. Int J Sci Res 2014;3:914-7.
Sorenson SB. Gender disparities in injury mortality: Consistent, persistent, and larger than you'd think. Am J Public Health 2011;101 Suppl 1:S353-8.
Miller S, Belizán JM. The true cost of maternal death: Individual tragedy impacts family, community and nations. Reprod Health 2015;12:56.
Haaga PT, Elechi FA, Okoye AC. Violence against women and its implication for peace and security in Nigeria. Int J Pharmacol Clin Sci 2015;2:27-40.
Meneghel SN, Hirakata VN. Femicides: Female homicide in Brazil. Rev Saude Publica 2011;45:564-74.
Fobil JN, Aryee E, Bilson F, May J, Kraemer A. A review of the structure and function of vital registration system in Ghana: Towards improvement in mortality data quality for health policy analysis. J Public Health Afr 2011;2:e5.
Sarfaraz L, Faghih N, Hajd AA. The relationship between women entrepreneurship and gender equality. J Glob Entrep Res 2014:4:2-11.
Mandong M, Madaki JK, Mohammed AZ, Kidmas AT, Echejo GO. Epidemiology of accident deaths in Jos, Nigeria (1996-2000). Ann Afr Med 2006;5:149-52.
Etebu EN, Nwosu SO. Medicolegal autopsies in Port Harcourt, Nigeria. Niger J Orthop Trauma 2003;2:33-5.
Akhiwu WO, Nwafor CC, Igbe AP. A 20 year retrospective analysis of medicolegal deaths in a tertiary hospital setting in Nigeria. Niger J Clin Pract 2013;16:535-9.
] [Full text]
Amakiri CN, Akang EE, Aghadiuno PU, Odesanmi WO. A prospective study of coroner's autopsies in university college hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria. Med Sci Law 1997;37:69-75.
Minniti M, Arenius P. Women in Entrepreneurship. United Nations Headquarters; 2003.
Conroy AA. Gender, power, and intimate partner violence: A study on couples from rural Malawi. J Interpers Violence 2014;29:866-88.
Umoh D. Death is not natural. J Relig Soc 2012;14:1-13.
Kemp A, Sibert J. Childhood accidents: Epidemiology, trends, and prevention. J Accid Emerg Med 1997;14:316-20.
Viner RM, Coffey C, Mathers C, Bloem P, Costello A, Santelli J,et al
. 50-year mortality trends in children and young people: A study of 50 low-income, middle-income, and high-income countries. Lancet 2011;377:1162-74.
Barcelos RS, Del-Ponte B, Santos IS. Interventions to reduce accidents in childhood: A systematic review. J Pediatr (Rio J) 2018;94:351-67.
Agbonkhese O, Yisa L, Agbonkhese EG, Akanbi DO, Aka EO, Mondigha EB. Road Traffic accidents in Nigeria: Causes and preventive measures. Civ Environ Res 2013;3:90-9.
Olobomohin OO. The development and impact of motorcycles as means of commercial transportation in Nigeria. Res Humanit Soc Sci 2012;2:231-9.
Rancic N, Djuruvic G, Pilipovic F. Medicolegal characteristics of defense injuries in cases of homicide. Vojnositetski Pregl 2017;74:335-40.
Okeke VO. The Nigerian state and the proliferation small arm and light weapons in the Northern part of Nigeria. J Educ Soc Res 2014;4:415-27.
Olugbenga SA. Adulterated kerosene burn disaster: The Nigeria experience. Ann Burns Fire Disasters 2005;18:40-4.
Nwachokor FN, Ijomone EA, Uchendu OJ. A forensic study of unnatural death in Warri, Delta state, Nigeria. Int J Forensic Med Invest 2016;3:8-18.
Seleye-Fubara D, Etebu EN, Athanasius B. Pathology of deaths from carbon monoxide poisoning in Port Harcourt: An autopsy study of 75 cases. Niger J Med 2011;20:337-40.
Aliyu I, Ibrahim Z F. Accidental carbon monoxide poisoning in a family of six: Diagnosis and treatment challenges in a resource limited setting. J Med Invest Pract 2014;9:130-1.
Edelu BO, Odetunde OI, Eke CB, Uwaezuoke NA, Oguonu T. Accidental childhood poisoning in Enugu, South-East, Nigeria. Ann Med Health Sci Res 2016;6:168-71.
] [Full text]
Vijayakumar L. Suicide in women. Indian J Psychiatry 2015;57:S233-8.
] [Full text]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]